Interpreting Results, Visual Analytics, and Option Comparison
Article icon

Interpreting Results, Visual Analytics, and Option Comparison

Results Summaries, Benchmark Grading, and Estimates Handling

The Results Summary tab consolidates calculated data into key performance indicators, normalized metrics, and standardized benchmark ratings.


Summary Benchmarks & Display Configuration

  • Normalized Intensity Metric: Emissions are evaluated per square meter of gross internal floor area (\text{kg CO}_2\text{e}/\text{m}^2).
  • Embodied Carbon Rating Scale: Projects are awarded a letter grade ranging from A++ (highest performance) down to G (highest impact).
  • EN 15978 Life Cycle Boundaries:

    • Cradle-to-Practical-Completion (Modules A1–A5): Total emissions generated from raw material extraction through site construction.
    • Whole Life Carbon (Modules A–C): Total emissions across all operational and end-of-life stages.
  • Display Controls: Toggle visibility of Title Blocks, Descriptions, Assumptions, Data Tables, and Graphical Charts.
  • Industry Benchmark Estimates: Toggle calculated estimates on/off for site activities (A5a) and demolition/deconstruction (C1). Benchmark factor origins are maintained under Preferences > Project Defaults (Structure Only Factor vs. Whole Building Factor). When estimates are active, reports display an explanatory footnote indicating calculated values.


Visual Analytics: Stage, Material, and Element Breakdowns

Dynamic visual charts transform tabular numbers into actionable graphical analytics:

  • Stage & Module Graphs: Evaluates total GWP impact distributed across individual lifecycle modules (A1–A3, A4–A5, B, C1–C4). Displays relative contributions alongside stacked emission totals.
  • Material Breakdowns: Identifies key material emission drivers across structural types (e.g., steel vs. timber vs. concrete) and refined sub-categories (e.g., hot-rolled steel sections vs. bar and rod reinforcement).
  • Element & Sub-component Graphs: Pinpoints structural emission hotspots by comparing functional element groups (e.g., Superstructure Frame vs. Upper Floor Slabs).
  • Operational Energy & Water Graphs: Displays energy split by consumption type (electricity vs. fuel) and application (heating, cooling, general power), alongside net operational water usage metrics.
  • Global Warming Potential (GWP) Snapshots: Details individual resource emission contributions across every stage from manufacturing through Module D benefits.


Side-by-Side Design Option Comparison

Evaluating structural design alternatives side-by-side allows teams to select optimal, low-carbon solutions.

                  ┌─► Scheme A (Steel Frame Option)     ──┐
│ │
PROJECT CONTAINER ┼─► Scheme B (Concrete Slab Option) ──┼─► [COMPARISON TOOL] ──► Comparative Analytics
│ │ (A1–A5 & A–C Boundaries)
└─► Scheme C (Mass Timber Option) ──┘

Procedure for Comparative Analysis
  1. Navigate to the top-level Project screen.
  2. Select two or more generated reports (e.g., competing structural schemes or progressive phase submissions).
  3. Click Compare.
  4. Evaluate side-by-side analytical outputs:

    • Compare normalized intensity scores (\text{kg CO}_2\text{e}/\text{m}^2) across Cradle-to-Practical-Completion (A1–A5) and Whole Life Carbon (A–C) boundaries.
    • Review comparative stage, material, and element charts.
    • Identify missing dataset entries across schemes (e.g., an early scheme lacking operational energy inputs will show an empty energy bar relative to complete schemes).
  5. Mark the preferred report as the Final Baseline Report to establish primary project portfolio statistics.